FUEL’S PARADISE

We pay polluters to pollute. Then we pay again to clean up the mess.

Governments around the world spend over a trillion dollars a year directly holding down the price of fossil fuels. Count the hidden costs of pollution and climate damage, and the IMF puts the bill at several trillion. We subsidise the problem and tax the solution. It is like paying a man to smoke and then funding his chemotherapy.

Subsidies are meant to help the poor. Mostly, they help the rich. The person with three cars gains more from cheap fuel than the person with a cycle. Cheap fuel encourages waste, burdens budgets and makes clean energy look expensive by comparison.

India has walked part of the road. Petrol and diesel prices were freed from government control. Support has shifted towards solar, wind and electric mobility. But coal and cooking fuel still carry heavy support, and every price hike sparks protests. Here is the way forward.

SWITCH THE SUBSIDY — Move money from fossil fuels to clean energy, public transport and efficiency.

TARGET THE TRULY POOR — Direct cash transfers protect the vulnerable without making fuel cheap for everyone.

PRICE THE CARBON — India's carbon credit trading scheme is a beginning. A clear carbon price tells markets which way the wind blows.

GRADUAL, NOT RADICAL — Phase subsidies out slowly and predictably. Shock therapy triggers street protests and policy U-turns.

Fuel's paradise is a fool's paradise. The longer we live in it, the harder the fall.