How should a nation give away what it owns? Spectrum. Coal. Minerals. Gas. For years, the answer was first come, first served. It was fundamentally flawed. It rewarded chance, not merit. The answer was the auctioneer’s hammer.
Much has changed since.
THE COURTS. In 2012, the Supreme Court cancelled 122 telecom licences. In 2014, it cancelled the allocation of 214 coal blocks.
THE LAW. In 2015, auctions became the rule for coal and major minerals. Spectrum is now auctioned too. Price discovery replaced paper discretion.
That was a genuine reform. But sustainability asks a harder question. Is the highest bid the same as the best outcome?
Not always. A mine can win on price and still lose on everything else. The forest that is cleared, the river that is diverted and the village that is moved never appear on the bidding sheet.
So the next reform needs a better bid. It needs a BID.
B for BENEFIT SHARING. People who live on top of a resource must share in its value. District Mineral Foundations were created for this. Their funds must reach people, not just projects on paper.
I for INTEGRITY OF THE LAND. The winning bid must include the full cost of restoring what is taken. A mine should be judged by how it closes, not only by how it opens.
D for DISCLOSURE. Every allocation, every bid, every royalty and every rupee of community funds should be public, in real time. Sunlight remains the best auditor.
There is one resource where first come, first served still rules. Water. Beneath our fields, the deepest borewell wins. Whoever drills first and deepest takes the most. That is the same flaw, only underground. As India’s aquifers fall, groundwater must be treated as a shared trust, not a free-for-all.
The principle still stands. Merit over chance. Accuracy over speed. Transparency over power. Only the stakes have grown. Spectrum can be auctioned again. A forest, an aquifer or a river cannot. When a natural resource goes under the hammer, it must be sold as if it can never be bought back. Because it cannot.
Sources: Supreme Court of India (2G judgment, 2012; coal allocation judgment, 2014); Mines and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Amendment Act, 2015; Coal Mines (Special Provisions) Act, 2015.
